The World Federation of Exchanges (WFE) has recently published a pivotal report urging regulators to take decisive action against the unchecked expansion of private markets. This growth, the WFE argues, poses systemic risks to financial stability, investor protection, and market transparency. Titled Strengthening Private Markets, the report highlights the growing tensions between public and private capital formation and advocates for a comprehensive overhaul of how the financial system supervises and integrates private capital structures.
The Rise of Private Markets
Private markets, once the domain of institutional investors, have surged in size and influence, driven by targeted policy incentives, favorable tax treatments, and lower disclosure obligations. This shift has drawn significant capital away from public markets, raising concerns about the long-term implications of such growth without adequate regulatory oversight. While the WFE acknowledges the essential role of private capital in the financial ecosystem, it warns that the current trajectory could lead to detrimental consequences.
Public Markets: The Backbone of Capital Markets
Nandini Sukumar, CEO of the WFE, emphasizes the critical role of public markets, stating, “Public markets remain the critical infrastructure that underpin capital markets – they are the gold standard, providing liquidity, authoritative pricing, equal access, regulatory oversight, and system-wide confidence.” While private markets have their place, Sukumar insists that they must not undermine the benefits provided by public markets. The WFE’s report identifies three core risks stemming from the unmonitored growth of private markets.
Systemic Risk and Financial Stability
One of the primary concerns is the systemic risk posed by the bundling of leveraged private credit with equity instruments and other illiquid assets. These products often lack transparency regarding valuation and risk, leading to potential fragility in the financial system. As secondary trading of private assets increases, the intersection of these markets with retail capital becomes more pronounced, heightening the risk of systemic instability.
Retail Investor Exposure and Misaligned Protections
The lowering of barriers to entry through innovations like tokenization and platformization has opened private markets to retail investors. However, these offerings, originally designed for institutional investors, often come with limited disclosure, high fees, and low liquidity. The WFE warns that such conditions are fundamentally incompatible with existing investor protection frameworks in public markets. The report calls for immediate attention to risk communication standards, particularly as private funds aggressively market themselves to non-professional investors.
Secondary Trading and Market Integrity
As private assets increasingly trade in secondary markets outside traditional regulatory frameworks, the WFE raises concerns about the potential interference with public market pricing functions. This could introduce arbitrage risks and create information asymmetries. The report advocates for supervisory reporting of such trades and greater public disclosure to maintain market integrity.
Rebalancing the Regulatory Environment
To address these pressing issues, the WFE proposes a set of coordinated policy actions aimed at rebalancing the regulatory environment between public and private markets:
Harmonized Transparency Standards: The WFE argues for enforced transparency across both public and private markets to ensure that capital allocation decisions are based on comparable data.
Review of Tax and Regulatory Incentives: The report calls for a reassessment of current rules and incentives that favor private capital over public listings, including differences in disclosure obligations and corporate governance expectations.
Systemic Risk Oversight: Regulators are urged to assess the impact of leveraged and bundled products in the private space, particularly in illiquid and thinly traded secondary markets.
Support for Public Listings: To stem the flow of capital away from public markets, the WFE recommends creating a more attractive environment for IPOs by reducing unnecessary listing burdens while retaining essential investor protections.
Global Regulatory Initiatives
Richard Metcalfe, Head of Regulatory Affairs at the WFE, highlights that transparency, effective oversight, and informed regulation are prerequisites for sustainable growth. National regulators, including the UK’s FCA, France’s AMF, Singapore’s MAS, and Australia’s ASIC, are beginning to focus on bringing accountability to private markets. Valuable work is also being done by international standard setters like IOSCO, but the rapid growth of private markets necessitates intensified efforts.
The Need for a Balanced Approach
While the WFE acknowledges the beneficial functions of private markets—particularly in supporting early-stage innovation and specialized financing—it stresses that these advantages should not compromise systemic resilience. The report advocates for a model where private market development occurs within a regulatory framework that preserves the foundational role of public markets.
The WFE joins a chorus of global voices expressing concern over the rapid financialization of private markets. The shift of capital into unlisted vehicles, especially when combined with new technologies and looser compliance expectations, signifies a structural change in modern finance. While some of these changes have enhanced efficiency and broadened access, the WFE insists that policy must adapt swiftly to prevent imbalances from taking root.
Conclusion: An Interconnected Future
In conclusion, the WFE emphasizes that public and private markets are not in competition but are part of an interconnected whole. Public markets provide the “infrastructure of trust” for the global economy, and similar expectations must be applied to their private counterparts. The report calls for better international coordination and suggests that lessons learned from global standard-setting in public markets should inform how authorities engage with private capital in the future.
As the financial landscape continues to evolve, the WFE’s call for stronger regulatory action serves as a crucial reminder of the need for balance, transparency, and accountability in both public and private markets.
English 